The Yandere Came During the Night - Reviews

That was quite unsettling. I wasn't prepared for the extensive use of the (misleading) intrigue. Entering with an idea of what to expect, I won't complain. While the story's realism is questionable, the flawed characters feel very real – I actually found them all unlikable, save for SQY and a few supporting roles. Their captivating (and exasperating) nature kept me engaged despite my initial reservations.

The main reason I deducted a star was due to the lengthy monologues that unexpectedly delved into extensive backstory and context. These served to explain the characters' actions and the scene at hand, but they became tiresome, especially since I prefer to read every word without skipping. I almost stopped halfway through, finding them unnecessary yet crucial to the plot.

Regarding a comment I came across, another reader suggested that if the protagonist, YX, hadn't died in her original world, she might have crossed a line with her biological brother. That thought resonated with me.

I truly adore this book. The main character is charming and endearing, while the male lead is aloof yet not domineering. Their relationship stands out because, unlike most I've encountered, it implies a unique connection - as if they were twin siblings who shared a childhood bond but harbor deeper feelings, without being biological relatives. This soul-twin dynamic adds an intriguing aspect without crossing the line into clichés. Both characters display unwavering loyalty and possess a complex, yet mature dynamic, with elements of a yandere nature. Misunderstandings are minimal, and the relationship is a delightful balance of sweetness and depth. I've already translated this story three times myself and plan to revisit it once the official translation is complete (thank you for your hard work).

"It was incredibly captivating and delightful, perfectly aligning with my current inclination for a less intense political narrative. This one thoroughly满足了我的期待. Primarily centered around a domestic conflict with a political twist, it also boasted well-developed characters."

Honestly, the novel felt quite peculiar, one-dimensional, and its conclusion left me unfulfilled. I knew what I was getting into with a fake sibling romance, but there were moments where the male lead's behavior was borderline creepy. The fact that their relationship progressed when she was only 14 and he was around 20 or 21, despite it being young for the setting, raised eyebrows and surpassed my expectations in terms of complexity.

The protagonist's magical plant and luck powers, which resolved significant conflicts, struck me as a bit of a Deus ex machina. The main antagonist's actions shouldn't have gone unpunished; she should have been expelled from her family after the second mishap, considering their threats to disown them if they made any more mistakes. The justification for keeping her around, knowing she wasn't blood-related, was weak, especially since they were planning to marry – why care about disclosure then?

The ending was unsatisfactory due to the lack of depth for the romance. After resolving the main plot, there were just two chapters devoted to their love story and marriage, followed by abrupt conclusions. Discovering the pregnancy was a positive note, but the protagonist's rape and subsequent life as a prostitute were distressing. Additionally, the rushed resolution with the princess marrying the protagonist's biological brother felt contrived, with little emotional closure.

Overall, while the novel was decent with its quirks, the mismatch between my expectations and the content earned it a 3.5 out of 5. I gave it the extra point for the well-executed artwork in the manga adaptation.

I really enjoy this! :) This novel is one of the few that I managed to finish after a long time without getting bored. Usually, I abandon books near the end because they fail to captivate me, but with this one, I stayed engrossed till the very end. The plot, with its supernatural elements set in a historical backdrop, is something I find particularly appealing – it just feels natural and intriguing to me.

The foreshadowing adds an extra layer of excitement, making me eager to discover what's coming next. And yes, the presence of yandere theme definitely caught my attention. In summary, this book has everything I look for in a good read. That's all for now, but I must say, I'm thoroughly satisfied with my choice.

It wasn't exceptional, but I managed to finish it. As usual, Chinese historical novels tend to leave a sour aftertaste due to their depictions of pederasty and sexualizing underage characters. It's quite disappointing. Additionally, the female lead's portrayal comes across as cringeworthy. On the surface, she appears cool and powerful, but in reality, she's just another typical teenager with petty behavior.

Certainly! "Definitely. This novel is enjoyable. The main character is very direct and always expresses her thoughts openly. As for the male lead, (ﾉ´∀｀*) he's quite amusing - he spoils her a lot. I appreciate their possessiveness towards each other. It's a lighthearted read with a few minor plot inconsistencies, but they don't significantly impact the core story. If you're looking for a cute and moderate-drama tale, this would be a great recommendation."

"This series has my seal of approval. Initially, I had low expectations, but it exceeded my surprises! The main character (MC) is a strong woman with disabilities, specifically foot issues, which she accepts and embraces. Unlike many other stories where disabled characters miraculously recover, our protagonist remains disabled but still shines as a badass.

The disability adds depth to the narrative because it introduces new, realistic, and permanent stakes. Every event feels purposeful. While the series does focus on character appearances and some might criticize the portrayal of villains, I personally don't find these issues significant.

There are moments when the villains seem one-dimensional, but considering their age group and the story's grounded consequences, it fits. The male lead is a god-like figure, but he falls for the MC through genuine affection, not manipulation. Their relationship is heartwarming, with him genuinely caring for her, and his support enhances the story's dynamics.

What sets this period drama apart is how the characters breathe fresh life into familiar tropes. The conventional roles of the leads are reversed in an intriguing way, which prevents me from giving it a full 5-star rating. Overall, it's a solid 4/5 for its unique take on disability, relationships, and storytelling."

I truly relish reading this enchanting and heartwarming tale. Yu Ping Yan and Yu Xiang make the perfect adorable couple; I've revisited their story twice. I particularly enjoy exploring the evolving dynamics of their relationship, beginning as a brother-sister bond (not by blood) and blossoming into love.

Yu Ping Yan is an enigmatic ancient figure who had never experienced love until Yu Xiang entered his life. Once he does, his affection is intense and his character exudes a deep sense of care and tenderness towards her.

On the other hand, Yu Xiang is a feisty and independent woman, but her interactions with Yu Ping Yan reveal a more vulnerable side. Their daily connection and evolving relationship are both captivating and extraordinary, forming a harmonious and loving partnership.

While I may not particularly appreciate the occasional plotting (which isn't too detrimental), it paradoxically serves to strengthen the unbreakable bond and love that Yu Ping Yan and Yu Xiang share.

"I absolutely adore it! It evokes such strong emotions, feels delightful, and is incredibly enjoyable. Although the beginning isn't explicitly resolved, that's perfectly alright too. It's just so heartwarming, T^T. After trying some of the author's other works, this one stands out as my favorite."

Everyone loves a protagonist with a strong personality and the courage to confront those who underestimate her. Reading about how she intimidated others due to her paralyzed legs was quite entertaining. It was hilarious whenever her mere presence made others tremble – it was a delightful read overall, and the supporting characters were well-developed too. The author gave them equal significance.

However, I deducted one star because, regardless of the time period, openly displaying affection between siblings like that seems implausible for a pure relationship. In the story, everyone seemed to accept it without question, but in real life, it would be unusual. That part felt a bit exaggerated for me. Despite that, I still highly recommend this book.

This review contains significant spoilers! Warning: The novel in question has some extremely unsettling aspects. Here's a summary:

- The relationship between the two main characters felt unnatural and overly sexual, with the male lead, who is portrayed as creepy, having inappropriate advances towards his much younger sister, even sniffing her period blood.

- The male lead is depicted as a misogynistic, violent individual obsessed with his sister. His character lacks depth, displaying only two extreme emotions: doting on his sister and being erratic with others. Overall, the reviewer rates him 2.5/5.

- The female lead (FL) is described as strange and possessive. She behaves aggressively, often using a whip, and is overpowered (OP), which adds an unusual dynamic. Despite knowing he's not her biological brother, she acts as if they're twins and engages in intimate behavior, which the reviewer finds unsettling. The FL's character evolves from an initially intriguing "lucky charm" to repetitive, boring, and annoying. The reviewer gives her a rating of 1.5/5.

- The main antagonist, Shen Miao Qi (SMQ), the original FL, is portrayed as a spoiled and self-centered character. Her attempts to improve her life are disturbing and ineffective. The reviewer questions why the author portrayed her negatively and wonders where the FL's redeeming qualities, usually found in similar stories, disappeared.

- The sudden change in another character, Siyu, from hatred to love for the FL is confusing and unrealistic, transforming her life dramatically.

- The novel is criticized for being overly powerful (OP) and focusing on a twisted dynamic between a sickly groomer-like stepbrother and his sister, who sees him both as a brother and romantic partner.

- While the reviewer didn't outright hate the book, it left them feeling uncomfortable and disgusted due to its unconventional and disturbing themes.

In summary, the reviewer found the novel peculiar, with unsettling relationships and character developments, leading to a low overall rating.