Back to the ’90s to Make Movies - Reviews

I keep coming back to the final image of the film-within-the-film: Zheng Wen and Tong Xiaole, small backpacks on their shoulders, holding hands, boarding a train bound for the distant horizon. A honeymoon wedding instead of the lavish ceremony both families wanted. A spontaneous romantic journey serving as the true witness to their love. This is the thematic payload of the entire production, and it's beautiful. The train is such a loaded symbol — it's movement, it's departure, it's the unknown future. They're not running away; they're running TOWARD something. And the fact that they chose this over satisfying their parents' expectations ties into the whole theme of young people carving their own path in a society that still has very traditional ideas about marriage, family, and duty. The household registration booklet — that's another symbol I can't stop thinking about. In China, that booklet (hukou) is everything. It's official, it's legal, it's the state's recognition of your existence as a coupled unit. Secretly taking it from home is an act of quiet rebellion. It's not dramatic or violent — it's just two people deciding that their commitment to each other is more important than following the script everyone else wrote for them. And the film's structure itself mirrors this theme. The movie they're making doesn't start with the romantic meet-cute; it starts AFTER the love has already happened, and then it deals with the real work of making that love survive against practical pressures. The narrative choice to skip the falling-in-love part and focus on the staying-in-love part is itself a statement. Love isn't the destination; it's the beginning of something harder and more meaningful. Chi Ying's own journey parallels this — she's not starting from zero, she's starting from experience, and she's choosing to do this differently than the old ways. The film they make and the film they're in are both about choosing your own path.

There's a line in this chapter that I think captures the entire philosophy of the book: 'Our works are the foundation of our existence. But before we ever reach that light, the first thing we have to do is survive through our own efforts.' Chi Ying quotes a pioneer of cinema saying 'For that beam of light, I would gladly die'—and then immediately undercuts it with pragmatism. You have to live first. You have to survive first. The art comes after. This is the central tension of the whole narrative, isn't it? The conflict between art and commerce, between self-expression and serving the audience, between the ideal and the possible. And Chi Ying's speech is essentially a manifesto for choosing survival without abandoning art. She doesn't say 'forget art.' She says 'bring audiences back into theaters first. Only after that can we talk about anything else.' The WTO angle is symbolic too. The 'wolves are coming' metaphor isn't just about Hollywood—it's about modernization, about China opening up, about a whole industry facing the reality that its protective walls are temporary. France is the ghost of the future: a nation that loved cinema more than almost anyone, and still couldn't save it from going Hollywood. Chi Ying is essentially saying: don't be France. But there's another layer here that I can't stop thinking about. The Song Lin subplot runs parallel to this. She's an actress—someone whose art form is even more precarious than a screenwriter's. No steady job, auditioning constantly, unable to afford decent housing, vulnerable to exploitation by landlords. Her survival is even more immediate, even more physical. The landlord's harassment isn't just about money; it's about power. He thinks he can extract something from her because she has no other options. Chi Ying's professional survival and Song Lin's personal survival are two sides of the same coin. Both are young women in a system that wasn't built for them. Both have to be smart, strategic, and ruthless when necessary. The beatings of the landlord? That's survival too. That's choosing action over dignity because dignity doesn't keep you safe. The recurring motif of heat is interesting too. Beijing's sweltering summer, the stuffy dorm room, the electric fan that does nothing. Heat as pressure. Heat as discomfort. Heat as the environment these women have to endure just to exist. And the office with its air conditioning—temporary relief, borrowed comfort, a place to think and plan while the real world burns outside. I keep coming back to that image of Chi Ying at her desk, working on her screenplay, pager going off, knowing her friend needs her. The art she's creating and the life she's living are the same thing. Survival isn't the opposite of art—it's the foundation.

The opening scene is SO specific and I need to talk about it. Chi Ying wakes up and the first thing she notices is "a weathered, peeling ceiling" and "small floral bed curtains swaying gently in the breeze from a tiny electric fan." That pattern looked like something straight out of the last century. This is such a small detail but it immediately tells you everything — this is 1998, this is a student dorm, this is a life that hasn't been polished yet. Then there's the bus ride. "The academy gates gradually shrank into the distance behind her." I love how the author uses physical movement to mark the point of no return. She's literally leaving her old life behind as the bus drives away. No dramatic music, no slow motion — just a bus and a girl who knows she'll never go back. The description of the area around the film academy is gorgeous: "Crowds bustled back and forth amid the constant stream of traffic. Students came and went throughout the day. With graduation season underway, groups of graduates were everywhere, taking commemorative photos and posing for endless pictures together." This is a moment frozen in time — the last generation before everything changes. And the author knows it. But the worldbuilding goes deeper than aesthetics. The text explains that in 1998, private production companies couldn't even obtain filming permits, cinemas were closing across the country, and ordinary people preferred television. This is the FINAL WINTER before the dawn. Chi Ying knows something no one else does — that within three years, China's box office would explode. The contrast between the bleak present and the glorious future she remembers creates this incredible dramatic irony. Every scene feels weighted with knowing.

Let me just say this: the opening scene of these chapters is cinematic perfection. Three in the morning. The crew arriving before dawn to block the scene and set up cameras because they're relying on natural light. Summer dawn breaking early. By the time the actual residents of the alley start heading out for their day, the crew has already finished and packed up. Not a single junior student helper needed to do anything because everyone was already done. This is such a specific, grounded detail that immediately tells you everything about this production — they're not some bloated state-owned studio operation with endless resources, they're lean and efficient and genuinely passionate. And then the breakfast scene! Sun Yanyan pushing the breakfast cart and being stunned by their efficiency, the mung bean soup buckets delivered by the private restaurant every day, the courtyard gathering. The worldbuilding here is so organic — you learn about the production's budget constraints, the cafeteria situation, the meal arrangements, the film stock concerns, all through casual conversation and action rather than exposition dumps. The guesthouse becomes this temporary home for the crew. Lu Wei eating steamed buns while watching the monitor. Chi Ying surrounded by junior cinematography students. The contrast between the professional seriousness of the work and the domestic warmth of their living situation creates this really lovely atmosphere. And the actual filming locations — the alley, the courtyard, the processing lab — they all feel real and lived-in. This isn't a glossy studio production; it's a movie being made by people who love movies, in real places, with real light. The world feels alive because it IS alive.

The pacing in these chapters is actually really interesting because it mirrors the filmmaking process itself. You've got the early morning rush, the efficient shooting, the smooth progression through scenes — and then there's this deliberate slowing down in the middle where we get all the backstory about the film's plot, the characters of Zheng Wen and Tong Xiaole, the family conflicts. It's almost like the narrative is taking a breath, letting you sit with what they're creating. And then — boom — 'The entire film was shot in just one month.' One sentence. One paragraph. We go from scene-by-scene detail to the wrap. It's a structural choice that actually works because it mirrors how filmmaking feels: these long days of meticulous work, and then suddenly it's over and you're standing there in disbelief. The transition from the first day of shooting to the wrap party is handled with this same economy. We don't get every single day documented — we get key moments, key conversations, and then the culmination. The wrap party itself is where the pacing really pays off. All that tension Chi Ying was holding — 'she had actually been on edge the entire time' — finally releases. The toast, the toasts to the teachers, the emotional breakdown. It's the release valve after a month of controlled pressure. And the ending — Professor Shen offering to introduce Chi Ying to promising students, the teachers recognizing her potential — it sets up the next phase without rushing it. The structure here is confident. It knows when to linger and when to move fast. It trusts the reader to fill in the gaps. And honestly, that's a mark of really skilled storytelling.

I need to talk about the Song Lin scene because my heart is actually hurting right now. On one hand, you've got Chi Ying in that conference room, absolutely dominating, giving this firebrand speech about the Chinese film industry needing to survive, about serving the people, about making films that ordinary audiences want to watch. She's on top of the world. The vice minister is praising her. Lei Dongming is applauding. She just got handed a project and the chance to make her first film. Everything is going right. And then—cut to that pager going off late at night. Tan Yi calling. Song Lin having nowhere to go. The landlord demanding a rent increase, then crossing the line, then refusing to leave, then shutting the door. Song Lin escaping with her life. Calling Tan Yi and the guys because there's no evidence for the police. Beating the scumbag half to death. Having to pack everything and run to her friend's place in the middle of the night. The text says 'Seeing how drained Song Lin looked, Chi Ying didn't ask many questions. She simply poured her a glass of water to help.' That's it. That one line. No dramatic speech, no 'are you okay?'—just water. Because sometimes the most loving thing you can do is not make someone relive it. And Chi Ying's dorm room! Single room, no air conditioning, sweltering Beijing summer, electric fan, stuffy without airflow. She actually prefers the office because it has AC. She can't even afford to install one. And yet she opens her door to a terrified friend in the middle of the night. What hits me most is how these two emotional worlds collide. Chi Ying just conquered a room full of veteran filmmakers, and her real victory is sharing a cramped dorm with her best friend who needs her. One is professional triumph, the other is something far more human. I kept thinking about how Song Lin auditioned for film crews all day, drenched in sweat, only to come home to a nightmare. And Chi Ying was there, already working overtime, already stressed about convincing Lei Dongming to invest, and she still made space. This friendship is the emotional anchor of the whole story. Everything else—the politics, the film industry drama, the career climbing—none of it matters as much as this moment of two young women in a hot room, one pouring water for the other.

Okay so let me just say—this chapter is where everything flips. Chi Ying's past-life knowledge isn't just some lazy cheat code the author hands her; it actually changes the ENTIRE trajectory of events. In her previous life, Zhao Xuemei was the one who eventually exposed Zhang Yang's affair, and even then it was after Chi Ying had already suffered through years of being undermined. But this time? Chi Ying gets the receipts BEFORE the damage is done. She walks into that confrontation with Zhang Yang knowing exactly about the motel, the hotel receipts, everything. That's not just a plot twist—that's a complete restructuring of the power dynamic. What's brilliant is how the author uses this. The scene where Zhang Yang realizes someone told Chi Ying and immediately blames Tan Yi? That's the plot doing double duty—revealing Zhang Yang's paranoia while also showing how isolated he is. He can't even process that a woman outsmarted him without assuming a man was behind it. The author is basically using the plot to dissect his character in real time. And the subplot with Tan Yi losing his faculty position to some ministry official's kid? That's not filler. It's setting up the entire Beijing struggle that Chi Ying herself experienced in her past life. The parallel is intentional—she knows what hardship lies ahead for him because she lived through a version of it. That's smart foreshadowing, not random drama.

Okay so let me just say this one line from the text absolutely wrecked me: "Coupled with being completely blinded by love, she had promised that scumbag boyfriend they would stay together forever." And then later when Director Han asks about the boyfriend and Chi Ying just casually drops "He... started acting a little dishonest before graduation. We broke up." and sneers inwardly. I literally gasped. The way she carries this entire lifetime of regret in one casual sentence? Chef's kiss. What I love most is how the author handles the ex-boyfriend without even showing him. He's this ghost that haunts every decision Chi Ying makes. In her first life, she threw away a BEIJING PLACEMENT — a golden ticket with household registration and housing — for a guy who apparently was already being dishonest. The contrast between what she had and what she chose is almost painful to read. And now in this second life, she doesn't even flinch when asked about him. That's not indifference, that's survival. I also want to talk about Professor Liu. This woman comes in sweating and furious, yelling in Shanghai dialect, and honestly? I kind of love her. She's the only adult in this whole chapter who seems to actually give a damn. When she says "sometimes a single choice determines the road you'll walk for the rest of it" — that hit different. It's not just plot advice, it's the whole theme of the book in one sentence. And Director Han's question about the boyfriend... the subtext! She's not just being nosy, she's calculating whether Chi Ying will stay long-term or run after some man again. The workplace dynamics layered on top of the romantic history? I'm here for it.

"Just give me a few days." I literally stopped reading for a second because that line hit me so hard. Chi Ying asking Tan Yi to turn down what seems like a legitimate opportunity — a director actually wanting him for a lead role, something he's been starving for — and just... ask him to wait. She's basically asking him to trust her. And the most devastating part? She hasn't even told him WHAT she's going to offer him. She hasn't told him she wants to cast him. She just says "wait a few days" and sends him to hang around Computer Village like some vague instruction from the future. And Tan Yi. Sweet, desperate, career-stuck Tan Yi. He doesn't ask a single question. He just smiles and says "Alright. I won't join that production. I'll wait a few days for you." He trusts her completely even though she's asking him to gamble on nothing. I keep thinking about Chi Ying's internal monologue: "She was asking him to give up what seemed like an excellent opportunity." She knows the weight of what she's asking. She knows she's blocking one path in his life, and she feels obligated to offer another of equal value in return. That sense of responsibility — that she won't just take his trust without giving something back — that's what makes their relationship so beautiful. It's not romantic (at least not yet), but it's deeper than romance. It's two people who see each other clearly and choose each other anyway. And then the ending — Chi Ying closing her dorm door and realizing how nonsensical her request must have sounded. She's human. She's improvising. She's doing her best with information from a past life that may or may not be reliable. That vulnerability makes the whole moment so much more real.

I need to talk about Tan Yi because this chapter absolutely made me fall for him. Like, the way he shows up—literally and emotionally—is everything. Chi Ying's situation is settled, but his is a mess. He just lost his faculty position overnight, he's becoming a drifter in Beijing with no backup plan, and yet he still goes out of his way to help her move. That's not just kindness; that's the kind of loyalty that defines a character. But what really got me is the drinking scene. Chi Ying, slightly tipsy, makes this grand promise: "when I get to make movies, I'll definitely cast you as my leading man." And Tan Yi? He takes it seriously. He says "you said it yourself, don't go back on your word when the time comes." This is a guy who's just had his entire future collapse and he's still holding onto a promise made by someone who was basically a nobody too. That's not naive—that's hope, and it's devastating because we know how hard the road is. The dynamic between them is so quietly powerful. He walks her back to the dorm because he's worried about Zhang Yang waiting outside. He puts himself between her and Zhang Yang when things get ugly. He laughs when she tosses the pager back in her bag like it's nothing. This man is steady in a way that makes everything else in the story feel more urgent.

Okay I need to talk about Song Lin because this girl is genuinely one of the most wonderful humans in fiction and I don't say that lightly. When Chi Ying drops the bomb that she wants Song Lin to be the female lead, you'd think Song Lin would be jumping for joy, right? Wrong. She immediately goes into caution mode. She's worried about Chi Ying being too authoritarian, worried about offending people, worried about making too much noise. And then when Chi Ying mentions bringing in their upperclassmen, Song Lin circles names on the crew list and says she can contact them directly, and then she says she should MEMORIZE the names because they shouldn't bring the list with them. She's acting like an underground operative for Christ's sake. The scene where Chi Ying internally reflects on Song Lin's character is everything: "She was considerate of others in every little way, never wanted to inconvenience anyone, kept her mouth shut, and could be trusted with important matters." This is a friendship built on absolute trust and mutual respect. And then Song Lin insists on treating everyone to dinner because "the boys had indeed done her a huge favor" — she's grateful in a way that feels so genuine and warm. What kills me is how Song Lin handles the awkward silence after Chi Ying's question to Tan Yi. She immediately stands up and pours everyone more drinks to smooth things over. No drama, no making it about herself, just quietly keeping the peace. This woman is a treasure and I hope Chi Ying knows that.

The dialogue in these chapters is genuinely good, which surprised me. It's not literary or stylized — it's the kind of natural, slightly messy conversation that actually happens between people who work closely together. Let me just collect some of my favorites because I need these for my own life. Sun Yanyan: 'Your efficiency is unbelievable. If every day goes like this, we'll only use half the film stock.' That's production-manager-speak but it's also character — she's worried about budget, she's practical, she's also capable of being genuinely impressed. Song Lin: 'I just hope I don't end up playing his mother in our next movie.' This line does SO much work. It's funny, it's self-aware, it reveals her career anxieties, and it establishes her relationship with Tan Yi all in one sentence. Chi Ying's response — 'You really do think way too far ahead!' while nearly choking on braised pork — is perfect comic timing in prose form. And then there's the toast scene where Chi Ying says 'Thank you, teachers. Without you, I'd have been completely lost. If you'd asked me to coach the actors myself, I honestly would've been intimidated.' That's not dialogue — that's a character admitting her limitations out loud, which is actually a really brave thing to write. The teachers' voices are distinct too. Professor Shen's offer to introduce promising students feels like something an older, connected academic would say. The junior cinematographers patting their chests and promising 'We'll always go in pairs' — you can hear their eagerness and youth. And Lu Wei, barely speaking but present throughout, eating while watching the monitor — his silence is its own kind of voice. The narrative voice itself is warm and observant without being overbearing. It doesn't tell you how to feel; it just shows you people being people.